I like to compare subjects to layers of a cake because they all connect and each has its unique importance. The ranking here is based on their relevance to a typical student’s future. Interestingly, even though STEM isn’t at the top, the perspectives can vary because nearly half of the teachers I asked were from social studies.
Here’s how they ranked the subjects. What’s your take on this list? Would you rearrange any?
Life Skills: Including health, financial literacy, college & career skills, social-emotional learning, home economics, etc.
Social Studies: Covering history, government, economics, geography, anthropology, psychology, sociology, etc.
English: Encompassing literature, creative writing, journalism, composition, rhetoric, etc.
Career Technical Education: Fields like mechanics, welding, design, cosmetology, etc.
Science: Subjects like physics, chemistry, biology, earth science, astronomy, etc.
Mathematics: Incorporating statistics, geometry, algebra, calculus, computer science, robotics, etc.
Fine Arts: Including film, music, dance, theatre, drawing, photography, ceramics, painting, etc.
Physical Education: With athletics, sports, track, weights, gym, etc.
World Language: Languages like Spanish, French, German, Japanese, Latin, etc.
Interesting that nearly 50% of your small sample were social studies teachers, and they ranked social studies highly. Also, some might categorize financial literacy under social studies too. It’s a thought-provoking observation but the survey method and analysis might limit its significance.
@Charlotte1
Likely from the same school too. They would naturally rate their specialty higher. Surprising that they don’t expect parents to teach life skills…
Smart said: @Charlotte1
Likely from the same school too. They would naturally rate their specialty higher. Surprising that they don’t expect parents to teach life skills…
It’s clear that life skills are crucial yet often overlooked. Nearly every teacher emphasized their importance, and sadly, many parents don’t cover these topics thoroughly.
@CatherineRivers
It’s a cycle where many adults haven’t learned these skills themselves, so they have nothing to pass on. It’s more pronounced in some groups than others.
Smart said: @CatherineRivers
It’s a cycle where many adults haven’t learned these skills themselves, so they have nothing to pass on. It’s more pronounced in some groups than others.
10th Grade (1 Credit): Health and Social-Emotional Learning
11th Grade (1 Credit): College & Career Skills and Personal Development
12th Grade (1 Credit): Financial Literacy and Home Economics
@CatherineRivers
Every state and even districts within them have different graduation requirements. Our state mandates health, a personal transition plan for post-graduation, and is working on including financial literacy.
@Charlotte1
Every teacher ranked Life Skills in their top three. Social Studies, English, and Career Technical Education are closely ranked. I acknowledge the sample size is small, but I appreciate your engagement.
@CatherineRivers
The concept is interesting, but the small and skewed sample size limits the survey’s credibility. To get a better understanding, it might help to include more teachers from your school. Additionally, defining what ‘real-life importance’ means could clear up any confusion among respondents about what you’re measuring.
Smart said:
Which high schools offer life skills and cosmetology classes?
Most states now have mandatory classes in health and financial literacy. Career and Technical Education (CTE) is also widespread, offering courses in various fields.
Smart said:
Which high schools offer life skills and cosmetology classes?
Many high schools in the USA combine regular academics with career-oriented programs, offering students a balanced education that prepares them for immediate employment after graduation.
@Brooklyn
Are these courses graded or are students choosing them because they think they’ll be easier? While it’s essential to teach these skills, they shouldn’t replace academic courses.
Smart said: @Brooklyn
Are these courses graded or are students choosing them because they think they’ll be easier? While it’s essential to teach these skills, they shouldn’t replace academic courses.
These programs are appealing because they provide both a diploma and employable skills. Students learn for free what others might pay for in career schools. Most of these courses do have assessments, combining practical and theoretical knowledge.
Financial literacy should cover topics like mortgage debt, insurance, wealth distribution, monarchy/feudal ownership, sex education, and nutrition and health.
zodiac said:
Financial literacy should cover topics like mortgage debt, insurance, wealth distribution, monarchy/feudal ownership, sex education, and nutrition and health.
Those are excellent suggestions! Here’s a proposed breakdown: 10th Grade: Health and Social-Emotional Learning; 11th Grade: College & Career Skills and Personal Development; 12th Grade: Financial Literacy and Home Economics.
The ability to manage money is crucial, regardless of your profession. Whether you earn a lot or little, knowing how to handle finances can determine the quality of your life.
Blair said:
The ability to manage money is crucial, regardless of your profession. Whether you earn a lot or little, knowing how to handle finances can determine the quality of your life.
Absolutely, financial management is vital, but there’s more to life like physical, mental, and social well-being. All these factors are incredibly significant.