When discussing the requirements for men to fight in wars without an equal number of women also being required, teachers have a range of responses. They typically encourage critical thinking and understanding historical contexts, while promoting open discussions in the classroom.
That’s a thoughtful point. Consider researching the history of the draft and the societal roles of women during those times. Understanding the reasons behind these decisions can provide more insight into your question.
Students are free to express their opinions in my class without my interference. And why would it be controversial to suggest that women should also fight in wars
Linah said:
Students are free to express their opinions in my class without my interference. And why would it be controversial to suggest that women should also fight in wars
Why is the necessity of war itself not viewed with more skepticism
@StudySage2
Students often aim to solve major global issues, a common phase of growing up. With time and experience, their perspectives usually mature.
If a student raises this question sincerely, it’s important to engage them with further questions to explore their views and consider various outcomes and alternatives. Class discussions should foster responsible and thoughtful debate.
Let’s keep our classroom discussions focused and avoid being derailed by potential distractions.
It’s an outdated system that the government enforces. My question is why any of my students have to register for the selective service at all
While it’s a valid question, it’s not something we’ll tackle in our classroom at this moment. There are better times and places for this kind of debate.
I personally believe no one should be obligated to fight in wars.
Elsie said:
I personally believe no one should be obligated to fight in wars.
While it’s nice to enjoy the safety of our society, remember that our stability sometimes depends on having a defense ready, which might necessitate a draft during crises.
oliviamartin said:
@Andy
Can you name a recent war that has genuinely protected the lives of people back home
Consider recent conflicts like those in Ukraine, which have broader implications, including for the US.
EdwardGenesis said:
@Andy
The discussion here is about American interventions, not global conflicts.
But the issue of war affects more than just the US. Every society must grapple with these questions.
EdwardGenesis said:
@Andy
The discussion here is about American interventions, not global conflicts.
Wars like those in the Gulf demonstrate the US’s readiness to respond to threats, albeit controversially.
EdwardGenesis said:
@JimGreenfield
Killing so many for uncertain benefits doesn’t stabilize American lives.
The effectiveness is debatable, but the idea was to deter further threats. Agreeing or not, these were decisions made by our leaders at the time.
EdwardGenesis said:
@JimGreenfield
It’s a problem when those decisions don’t clearly benefit the public.
Then we need to elect better leaders to make these decisions.