This question might seem like it’s about probability, but it’s more about the philosophical or existential view of our existence compared to insects. If this isn’t a question of probability, why might that be?
Kids often ask unexpected questions during lessons that can throw you off. It’s part of handling a classroom.
Leeland said:
Kids often ask unexpected questions during lessons that can throw you off. It’s part of handling a classroom.
Agree, it’s tricky. I had a student bring up an inappropriate topic recently, and I had to guide them away from it without sparking more curiosity.
Dolph said:
@Brianna
That probably just made them more curious!
Probably, but it’s part of the job to manage these things carefully and maintain classroom decorum.
I’d probably just be confused and ask them to clarify what they mean.
I’d explain that concepts like ‘winning’ are human constructs. Insects don’t contemplate these things—they just exist.
I would encourage them to explore their thought and share their views, and then we could discuss it further after class or during a more appropriate time.
That’s a great question for critical thinking. I’d turn it into a learning moment to discuss perspectives and maybe even touch on some biology and philosophy if time allows.
It’s a fun way to think about evolution and survival. Insects have been around much longer than humans and might outlast us!
I’d probably just say yes to keep things simple and move on.
Jokingly, I’d say I thought I won being human until I became a teacher, but that’s just humor to lighten the mood.
I’d acknowledge the question but remind them to stay on topic with the current lesson, like math or science.
It’s unlikely a student would ask this, but if they did, it’s a good prompt for a thoughtful discussion.
I’d relate it to probability and statistics, exploring the odds of being born as different species.
Is this a real question or just hypothetical?
Interesting, but let’s get back to the topic at hand, like photosynthesis, and we can discuss this later.
Our life starts where it does; we grow into who we are, not always starting as we end up.
Why assume being human is better? Each form of life has its own unique experience.
It’s almost a spiritual question. Scientifically, it doesn’t quite work that way. Spiritually, it’s about appreciating the life you have.